In commercial contracts—especially sale of goods and service arrangements—understanding conditions and warranties is essential for drafting, risk allocation, enforcement, and remedies. The distinction determines whether a breach allows termination or only damages, which is critical for supply, procurement, and banking vendor contracts.
Meaning
- Condition: A condition is a fundamental stipulation that goes to the root of the contract; breach entitles the aggrieved party to treat the contract as repudiated and claim damages.
- Warranty: A warranty is a collateral or secondary stipulation; breach gives a right to damages but not to terminate the contract.
Practical difference
- Consequence: Breach of a condition permits rescission plus damages; breach of a warranty permits damages only.
- Reclassification: In some cases, a breach of condition may be treated as a breach of warranty (e.g., where the buyer waives the condition or has accepted the goods), but not vice versa.
Implied conditions
- Title: In a sale, the seller implicitly promises the right to sell; any defect in title allows the buyer to reject and claim damages.
- Description: Where goods are sold by description, they must correspond with that description; mismatch is a breach of condition.
- Merchantable/satisfactory quality: Goods must be of merchantable quality where the sale is by description from a seller who deals in such goods; latent defects that make goods unfit breach this condition.
- Fitness for purpose: If the buyer makes known the particular purpose and relies on the seller’s skill or judgment, goods must be reasonably fit for that purpose.
- Sample and sample plus description: In a sale by sample, the bulk must correspond with the sample, the buyer must have a reasonable opportunity to compare, and the goods must be free from latent defects; where both sample and description apply, the goods must match both.
- Deliverability and time (where essential): Stipulations as to deliverability, and time as a condition where expressly made essential, may be implied or agreed depending on context.
Implied warranties
- Quiet possession: The buyer is entitled to quiet possession; interference by someone with better title breaches this warranty.
- Freedom from encumbrances: Goods should be free from undisclosed charges or encumbrances; otherwise, the buyer may recover losses.
- Quality and disclosure in trade usage: Where usage of trade implies warranties as to quality or disclosure of known defects not apparent on examination, failure may constitute breach of warranty.
- Reasonable care in services: In service contracts, a warranty of reasonable care and skill is commonly implied unless excluded, ensuring performance to professional standards.
Banking and finance relevance
- Vendor contracts: Classifying uptime commitments, data security, and regulatory compliance as conditions allows termination for serious breaches; routine service levels or reporting can be framed as warranties with liquidated damages.
- Collateral and title: In secured lending, warranties on title, absence of encumbrances, and authority to create charge protect enforceability; conditions can be tied to perfection, filings, and covenants fundamental to drawdown.
- Fintech and outsourcing: Fitness for purpose, data integrity, and compliance with law may be drafted as conditions; support response times and updates can be warranties with service credits.
- Sale of repossessed assets: Descriptive accuracy and title warranties reduce dispute risk; explicit exclusions should be balanced against statutory implied terms where applicable.
Drafting tips
- Tag the truly critical promises as conditions, expressly stating that breach gives a right to terminate and claim damages.
- Use warranties for ancillary assurances; specify exclusive remedies and caps for warranty breaches to manage exposure.
- Avoid ambiguity by stating whether time is of the essence and when a condition may be treated as a warranty by agreement or acceptance.
- Align inspection rights, acceptance tests, and sample/description clauses with remedy provisions to avoid mismatches.
- Include disclosure schedules to qualify warranties and limit post‑closing disputes in asset and loan portfolio sales.
Remedies and strategy
- For conditions: Rescission, rejection of goods/services, and damages; consider specific performance where appropriate.
- For warranties: Damages measured by loss flowing from the breach; consider price adjustments, service credits, or repair/replace obligations.
- Evidence and risk: Maintain acceptance certificates, inspection records, and reliance statements to support or defend claims about description, quality, and fitness.
- Waiver management: Train teams not to inadvertently waive conditions through acceptance, partial performance, or inconsistent communications.
XXXX
